Skip to content
Real World Example: The Hidden Cost of Not Negotiating Buyer Agent Commission
Most homebuyers don’t realize just how much money is on the line when they accept the “standard” buyer agent commission. While 2.5% may sound set in stone, it’s absolutely negotiable—and failing to negotiate can cost you thousands of dollars.
Let’s look at a real-world example that makes this point crystal clear.
The Scenario: A Desirable Home in a Buyer’s Market
A desirable home hit the market and, within just three days, already had an offer on the table. Before the seller had accepted it, a second buyer came along, eager to submit their own offer.
Here’s what happened next:
- The seller’s agent told the second buyer’s agent that the first offer was
“competitive.” - The second buyer’s agent advised offering the full asking price plus an
escalation clause, meaning the buyer would automatically outbid any competing offers by $1,000 increments, up to $5,000 over asking. - This strategy effectively pushed the buyer into a bidding war—even though it was supposed to be a buyer’s market.
Where Negotiation Could Have Changed Everything
Instead of exposing themselves to higher costs, the second buyer could have flipped the script.
By negotiating their buyer agent’s commission down from the industry-standard 2.5% to 2%, they would have instantly made their offer more attractive to the seller without raising the purchase price.
Why? Because from the seller’s perspective, a lower commission means more money in their pocket. That alone can make a “standard” offer rise above the competition—without the buyer paying more.
The Real Cost
Here’s how it played out:
- The second buyer ended up getting the home under contract for $240,000 after escalation.
- Had they negotiated the commission down to 2%, they could have confidently offered just the asking price and still likely outshined the first offer.
- That would have saved them around $6,000—buying the same house for
$235,000 instead of $240,000.
Key Takeaway: Don’t Leave Money on the Table
This example makes one thing clear: blindly accepting a 2.5% buyer agent commission can cost you thousands. Negotiating just half a percent may mean the difference between overpaying and walking away with significant savings.
If you’re buying a home, don’t assume industry standards are fixed. Push back, ask questions, and negotiate—because every dollar saved in commission is a dollar you keep in your pocket.
Final thought: In a buyer’s market especially, you hold the leverage. Use it.
Negotiate that commission.
